I posted my previous entry and got a few retweets and favorites. One reply came back and made me think, “ah, it might not be obvious why I’d like to have F# on something besides Windows.” Well, here’s a list of why I want to use F# on non-Windows platforms.
- F# is a good language. I can’t say the best, since I honestly don’t have enough experience with it or other functional languages to really declare a victory in my opinion. However I’ll be doing some work with Scala, Haskell, and Erlang in the next couple of weeks for testing and use with some upcoming projects.
- The community around F# is actually pretty cool, there are good, solid, intelligent, and friendly people in that community. Having a good community of people always makes getting into a new language or related tech much better then when the community consists of asshats or jack ass savants.
Other great things that add to the usefulness of F# include WebSharper, .NET MVC 5 and Web API, Nancy API, Suave.io, and there are others.
So those are the reasons I decided to move forward with F#: solid language, provides a solid technical stack with options, it’s functional and clean with extra compute power, and a kick ass community. Of course F# came from the land of Windows and Softies (that’s short for Microsofties, and I didn’t make that up). But F# was handed over to the open source community and currently moves forward autonomously of Microsoft. By proxy of this event, and other culminating events of late, F# can easily run on operating systems besides Windows. I’m not a fan of Windows, and here’s a few snarky (yet very real) reasons why I don’t even want to mess with Windows (except in the situation where I really do want to or need to use Visual Studio).
- Windows is still slow. I could go into the reasons, but it tends to build slow, behave slow, be prone to the attention of spammers and such, only in the last X years has it managed security in a half ass decent way, which also leads to slowness, and … oh you get the idea. It’s a slow OS.
- It’s flippin’ humongous. Now is this really a problem? Not really, but it’s annoying to force fit it in when I’m doing DevOps work or actually attempting to load Windows related images with it. The OS itself is still a nightmare of gigantic proportions compared to spooling up other systems. If one wants to fight with it, that’s great, I don’t really feel a keen desire to fight with it.
- Linux == Smaller footprint, more features, let’s not bring up security, is actually used on major systems, large scale systems and super-computers. Windows has less than 2% market share in that space. Even Microsoft is decreasing their reliance on Windows, offering oodles of Linux options.
- Windows doesn’t tend to get, run, or have the bleeding edge tech options built for it. Go look at the open source massive distributed systems applications and other excellent leading platforms and tooling that are leading companies into the future. If Windows is involved at all, it’s often an afterthought. :-/
- Windows 8 interface. I’m just going to leave that one right there. I like a lot about it, but I’m with Microsoft, even with Windows 10 they’re not trying to push this UI/UX catastrophe any longer.
- SSH not built in. End of story.
Don’t get me wrong, the tooling on Windows for doing Windows specific development and even doing crud apps with lots of business rules is spectacular. I’d even bet that the .NET ecosystem does a better job, sometimes dramatically better, than the Java ecosystem when it comes to those types of applications. I however, haven’t built these style of applications in a long while. Whenever I do, Windows might be a prime option, but otherwise I’ll stick to the operating systems that get me into the coding faster, sooner, and with less resistance.
Outside of Windows there are a lot of great Microsoft tools and technologies that I’d love to have on non-Windows operating systems. One of those is F#. Another is Visual Studio, which I’m betting will continue to get better and better. I’d like to have C# (which I do with Xamarin and such) and a whole ton of other scaffolding and crud tools and other things that are available. I just prefer them without Windows.
As I often say, to each their own. Mine just isn’t Windows these days.
12 thoughts on “Why F#, and Why Not Windows”
Great aritcle Adron. I’m looking at a lot of different languages that will make my web design work easier. Grammar nitpick:
“related tech much better then”
“much better **than**”
…and aritcle is spelled article. 😛
Thanks! Fixin’ that now. 🙂
Also, in item 2., you meant “latter,” not “later.” 🙂
What OS do you prefer then? And what do you use for IDE on that OS?
These days I tend to prefer OS-X for general productivity work and as a core OS. Simple, lightweight by most standards, tons of compatibility with gadgets, and runs VMs really well via VMWare Fusion or such. If I’m working on a hard core powerful dev machine I prefer to just use Ubuntu or some Linux variant.
Kick ass!! 🙂
I call bullshit.
No quantifiable evidence backing such claims of windows being slow and feature-less than Linux.
We are technologist. We use what technology solves our problems.
Making claims against windows like that makes you just another asshat savant as you so describe.
I really liked your article. I agree 100% about your feelings with f#. The community aspect is almost weird… Like no one has ruined it yet. It’s still pure rather. Like the early stages of Go… I almost don’t want it to get to popular for that reason.
I hate commenting. You’re not an asshat savant.
Thanks and keep posting.
“I really liked your article. I agree 100% about your feelings with f#. The community aspect is almost weird… Like no one has ruined it yet. It’s still pure rather. Like the early stages of Go… I almost don’t want it to get to popular for that reason.”
You’re not an asshat savant either! 😛
I agree with you about Windows. As a Linux person I’ve been using OCaml for the last few years. Can you comment about the advantages of F# over OCaml on Linux?
I wish I could, however I’m not experienced enough with both to really lay out the differences.
Comments are closed.